TO: Mr. Salgado and Mr. Sanchez
Re: IT Program for Zara
Before we meet with the IT consultants this evening, I would like to review the problem at hand and offer my position as of now. Let me begin with praise for Zara. This company has been flourishing, expanding, and prospering and ensuring this continued success is the top consideration when evaluating our IT options. When reviewing our current IT system, I find myself resorting to the old adage "If it ain't broke, don't fix it". However, it would be foolish to ignore the IT issue on a deeper and more long-term level.
Zara is faced with a dilemma. This company has been using a DOS-based POS system that is currently out of date. And while Zara is currently asymptomatic, it is likely that in the not-so-distant future, Zara will be at a disadvantage using this age-old system. The scope of this issue is vast: every Zara store is or would eventually be affected by a company wide change in its IT program and the adoption of a new operating system. When evaluating the possible options, we must be mindful of this. Further, we want to perform a cost-benefit analysis keeping in mind that a complete upgrade would impact over 500 stores internationally (growing daily). The chosen alternative would need to uphold our unique business model which focuses not only on design and production but also on distribution and sales within a decentralized organization. Our IT system must allow the following:
- employees to maintain their independence
- new Zara stores to open daily around the world
- revenues to continue to grow
- distribution centers to be accessible
- inventory to turn over quickly
- customers to continue enjoying the Zara experience with a seamless integration of new technology
- stores to be connected to each other and to distribution centers in live time
- PDAs and floppy disks to be discontinued
With this in mind let's review our options. Zara can continue using the current DOS system until it is no longer supported and we are forced to make a change or we can make a complete change to a Windows, Linux, or Unix operating system. Making a switch to one of these operating systems is the only way to avoid the current software being unsupported however it also requires significant time and money and should not be made without careful consideration.
When evaluating the alternatives we should first review the assumed costs. Unix is the most expensive program to purchase, followed by Windows, with Linux being the least costly. At 5 terminals per store with 500 stores (let's just work with round figures for now) that is a presumed minimum of 2500 terminals which would mean €350,000 for the licensing cost of Windows, €400,000 for Unix, but no licensing cost for Linux. However, the service contract for Linux would cost anywhere from €25,000 to €375,000 based on IT staff's knowledge. It is likely that since we would be developing a new IT department, the knowledge about Linux would be minimal to none unless we specifically sought employees who had experience with that system. In addition to the costs of the operating system itself, we are facing hundreds of thousands of Euros for POS terminals, routers, ethernets cards, Internet connectivity, programming time and installation and training time. The largest decision between these alternatives is which operating system is the best option for Zara. In addition to the cost of the operating system we choose, the other costs will remain constant. We want to make sure we refer to our list of "must-dos" and measure the pros and cons of each operating system.
At this point, I think it is wise to develop a larger IT department for Zara. We currently spend 5 times less than our competitors on information technology. We should create an IT team to begin the process of changing the operating system at Zara. I believe it is important to take our time in this change and be mindful of our options but waiting for the DOS system to loose support invites too much risk into our company. We have to take measures to make a change and the first step is researching each operating system and calculating the costs to implement this change in specific stores as a trial before going company wide.
It is my hope that the consultants this evening provide more information on the following:
- the operating systems difference, pros and cons
- the financials on the programming and financial costs
- the logistics for making change
- the timeframe for implementing change
- the proposed new flow of information from employees (stores) to DCs and headquarters
Further, I look forward to seeing charts that advise on the most effective way to create an informed and well developed plan on HOW to change and not simple provide an opinion on whether or not a change is necessary. Inevitably, our DOS-based POS systems and use of PDAs will be obsolete so we need to prepare and educate ourselves so that change can be well-developed, efficient, and most importantly beneficial to our ever-growing company. Our technology will never be turned over as quickly as our inventory and for that we can take a sign of relief.
POST PRESENTATION REFLECTION
After attending the presentation by the consultants, I still believe that Zara should begin a shift to a new operating system. Windows seems to be the option that would require the least amount of training as it was presented as being the most similar to the current DOS-based system making it a more cost effective option than Unix or Linux after considering customer support and employee training. The consultants suggested that shift begin in the Spain stores which seems like a reasonable suggestion and one that does not carry much risk. What is most important, is that employees be carefully guided through this changeover so that confidence levels can be maintained and work performance will also be consistent and stable. Because Zara has enjoyed such tremendous success, making major changes to IT may seem daunting and unnecessary. However, being an innovative company means being able to foresee future pitfalls and an aging operating system is likely to cause harm to the company if not properly addressed. With a shift to Windows, Zara can insure that its business model is supported and its daily operations will, in fact, improve.
POST PRESENTATION REFLECTION
After attending the presentation by the consultants, I still believe that Zara should begin a shift to a new operating system. Windows seems to be the option that would require the least amount of training as it was presented as being the most similar to the current DOS-based system making it a more cost effective option than Unix or Linux after considering customer support and employee training. The consultants suggested that shift begin in the Spain stores which seems like a reasonable suggestion and one that does not carry much risk. What is most important, is that employees be carefully guided through this changeover so that confidence levels can be maintained and work performance will also be consistent and stable. Because Zara has enjoyed such tremendous success, making major changes to IT may seem daunting and unnecessary. However, being an innovative company means being able to foresee future pitfalls and an aging operating system is likely to cause harm to the company if not properly addressed. With a shift to Windows, Zara can insure that its business model is supported and its daily operations will, in fact, improve.
