Tuesday, March 26, 2013

Three Times the Charm: Bombardier's ERP Rollout #3


To my fellow executives:

We at Bombardier are faced with our third ERP system implementation after two successful and drastic prior ERP implementations. Although we are not falling victim to specific problems or issues with our current system, a new ERP could improve the areas in which we are weakest. After ERP development at Mirable and Saint-Laurent a third ERP should meet the standards considered to be the highest ideals and the best practices. In order to meet these and achieve the highest level of ERP success, we must identify all areas that need to be sharpened. 

With our prior ERP developments we have identified the importance of user preparation and training. We first recognized this issue and tried to resolve it with the implementation at Saint-Laurent where our VP took an effective hands-on approach.  Currently, the communication in daily operations is often compromised and results in delays and duplications with processing and accounting. Managers also noticed reports that many supervisors seemed to have mastery of the new system and feel those employees should be recognized and distinguished. The KPI that were developed are not always being used but should be. Further, RFC were not all properly managed with the Saint-Laurent ERP development and should be revised during this third phase. The BMIS team also needs to address issues surrounding user expectations. We must tailor this implementation for the next facility and identify all potential users and how ERP will be used as a part of daily practice. The entire purpose of an ERP system is to keep all employees connected and to ensure that all daily practices are measured and monitored in an accessible, live manner. 

After assessing our current position, I will go into our consultation knowing that a third implementation is in order and that there are decisions to be made about how we can implement an ERP that meets all the highest standards while being cost-effective, efficient to the needs of Bombardier specifically with its inventory and sales. In order to do this, we must review what those ERP guidelines are. The list below was developed in 2002 by Pollyanne S Frantz, Arther R Southerland and James T Johnson:

1. Executive management should endorse the ERP project.
2. Executive management should remain actively involved throughout the implementation.
3. ERP software implementation responsibilities should be shared between the IT department and functional areas where the software is being implemented.
4. Executive management should be cognizant about the institution’s ability to adapt to the organizational changes that occur when ERP is implemented by being aware of Shock and Shock Relief.
5. A project manager should be assigned the full-time to the implementation.
6. The project team composition should represent all functional areas where the software will be implemented. Implementation through all systems.
7. Project team members’ normal job responsibilities should be reassigned to other employees for the project duration.
8. Employees should receive training on how to work as a team on a project before implementation begins.
9. The institution should retain ownership of the implementation process. “Skills transfer” from consultant to company.
10. All employees who will use the software should receive thorough training.
11. The institution should change its administrative processes to fit the software.
12. Implementation information should be continuously communicated to the business community.

#1 and #2 specifically speak to the importance of top management involvement which I believe to be a key distinguishing factor in this third implementation. #3 relates to the communication issues we are trying to improve and # 8 and # 10 state the importance of training which we know to be an area that Bombardier needs to improve. Each of these best practices need to be customized to our BMIS team so that our third implementation can reach the highest level of ERP implementation. I believe that each of these should be reviewed by the BMIS team as well as carefully explained and developed with managers and trainers. With sharpened communication practices and training that is well-developed and organized, this third phase ERP should be masterful and result in increased inventory tracking, decreased errors in processing and ultimately, overall growth in revenue. The key goal is for Bombardier to do this in a way that is seamless both internally and externally. 

I hope that the consulting team presents a clear list of the areas of the current ERP system that need to be revised. I would also like them to highlight the ways in which the previous two systems have helped improve the company in the areas of revenue and expenses. Further, I would like to be presented with financials with regard to a third ERP implementation that include expenses as well as expected revenue growth. I hope to have answers to the following questions:

-How much should this ERP implementation cost?
-How much will it save in the long run?
-When will we see measurable results?
-How long will training take?
-What are the options for support after the rollout?

I would like to be presented with the list of the best practices that I have listed for us to review in this memo and be "walked-through" with the consultants to evaluate which are currently used and which need to be a part of phase three. Ultimately, we need to be fully prepared and well-organized before this third ERP implementation begins and I am relying on the consulting team to present to us the best ways for Bombardier to achieve superior ERP functionality. We have done well thus far and should only continue to soar. 

Friday, March 8, 2013

Accenture Decision Memo

Fellow executives,

Our meeting with the consulting group on Tuesday evening solidified my decision that now is not the time to implement COBIT 5. In addition to the concerns I share with these consultants, they also noted that COBIT 5 is a generalized framework and suggested this may be an imperfect tool for such a highly personalized and well-developed IT system as we have at Accenture. 

To speak to my concern on the costs associated with COBIT 5, the consultants carefully itemized the expenses for training based on 500 employees to be between $1.7M and $2.3M. I would add that in a company with tens of thousands of employees 500 employees is a low-end estimate of the actual number of employees requiring training. In addition to the training costs, the team also suggested the additional personnel required for a 3-year implementation program would cost an additional $15M. Although the number of new employees hired and the salary they are paid may be altered, COBIT 5 still seems to require additional employees and at no small cost to Accenture. Before listening to the consultants, I had not accounted for the need to hire additional employees. Therefore, hearing this further convinced me that COBIT 5 would be an unnecessary expense for Accenture to incur at this time. 

While the consultants were clear and thorough in their presentation, I would like to reiterate my previous concern about the effects of this adaption on current employees. Although there is no direct dollar amount to attach to this area of hesitation, I believe it carries significant weight. Employees who have worked laboriously and diligently to create Accenture's stellar IT program could easily feel frustrated, under appreciated and resentful if a new framework were to be adopted. Let's not forget that these are the people who brought us to the level of success we are currently enjoying. 

In conclusion, I urge you to evaluate the costs (both monetary and emotional) associated with a COBIT 5 implementation. Once again, I offer my opinion that Accenture will not currently benefit from COBIT 5 and in fact, it will be a cost that I forecast to be detrimental to a well-crafted infrastructure. 

Monday, March 4, 2013

Accenture 2013: COBIT 5?

My fellow Accenture team:

In preparation for our meeting with the consulting firm tomorrow evening, I wanted to review our current position and consider what our options are. I hope that the consultation firm will be able to provide greater insight into our options and help guide a decision about maintaining the IT sector of Accenture.

As a global enterprise, Accenture has been exemplar in its transformation to an ERP system and in developing a business-within-a-business IT system and implementing the Global Delivery Network. From 2001 to 2010 we more than doubled our number of IT employees, our revenue doubled, and we increased the percentage of satisfied sponsors. All this while reducing IT money spent overall and as a percentage of revenue and per person. We decreased the number of global and local applications and switched from multiple technology platforms to just one. We are now faced with options on how to best maintain these results while staying true to the effective and flexible platform upon which Accenture designed its infrastructure. It is important to remember that this decision will be of a global and company-wide scope thus affecting thousands of employees around the world.  

Accenture has the option to implement the use of Control Objectives for Information and Related Technology (COBIT 5). According to its homepage, COBIT 5 is "the latest edition of ISACA’s globally accepted framework, providing an end-to-end business view of the governance of enterprise IT that reflects the central role of information and technology in creating value for enterprises. The principles, practices, analytical tools and models found in COBIT 5 embody thought leadership and guidance from business, IT and governance experts around the world." Further, COBIT 5 divides IT into the following divisions: Plan and Organize, Acquire and Implement, Deliver and Support, and Monitor and Evaluate. After our IT transformation, Accenture is currently independently managing these subdivisions already. There is great similarity in the practices of Accenture and the description of what COBIT 5 offers, namely in the planning, management, and execution of IT practices such as the use of a single-vendor platform as with the current ERP. Our business relationship with sponsors is already sound and our support expenses have decreased. Our current governance structure that is subdivided into strategy and structure, multi-year planning, annual planning and execution already includes most of what COBIT 5 offers. However, it's important to at least consider what COBIT 5 may offer Accenture in 2013 and beyond. That said, when deciding if Accenture should implement COBIT 5, we must determine the decision criteria. Does COBIT 5:

- allow Accenture to maintain its existing IT infrastructure: YES
-  allow Accenture to maintain its IT independence: YES
- require changes to the existing global ERP: NO
- disturb the business within a business structure that currently exists: NO
- keep Accenture flexible and efficient: NO
- support the ROI-orientation of the current IT budgets: NO

As you can see above, COBIT 5 becomes a risk to Accenture in terms of its cost to the company as well as the potential effects its adoption could have on employees. Implementing COBIT 5 would cost Accenture thousands of dollars in training. This money would have to be carefully budgeted to uphold the current IT practices. By adopting COBIT 5, Accenture would be loosing some of its independence. After the tremendous re-organzation and development of the IT structure, I am hesitant for Accenture to now implement a new and different framework. A greater concern is for the thousands of employees who are currently maintaining and governing Accenture's IT "business". Changing to COBIT 5 would mean not only training these individuals but also matching the confidence level they currently posses. All this without gaining anything that is necessary to improve or enhance Accenture. 

It is my hope that the consultants present the details about the offerings of COBIT 5 and how it would be similar and different from the current governance structure. A comparison chart would be very helpful in illustrating the pros and cons of a COBIT 5 system. I would also like to see a more specific breakdown of the costs associated with the potential implementation. We need to know exactly what is necessary to make this adoption and the costs associated with each. 

After we hear the presentation by these consultants we should meet to review and decide if COBIT 5 will be implemented or if Accenture should continue to perform as is. It will take significant convincing to sway me toward COBIT 5. I do not see any ways in which it will enhance the infrastructure we so carefully developed and am concerned it may introduce complication and concern to our exemplar team. 

For your reference: http://www.isaca.org/COBIT/Pages/default.aspx 

Sunday, March 3, 2013

uBuntu? iBuntu? weBuntu?

Ubuntu is a user-friendly, open source alternative operating system to Windows 7 and iOS - the two current operating systems that are used in our daily business practices. When evaluting a potential adoption of the Ubuntu system, I first insured that it was compatible with the programs that our business is dependent upon. Microsoft Office will run using Ubuntu so there was no problem is accessing and creating documents in Word, Excel and Power Point. More importantly, I was able to run the software that we use as our database: Mortuary Information Management System (MIMS). This software stores all of our files, links directly to our website, and helps create documents for storage and printing. Being able to run this program is essential for conducting business. Life Tributes, our video creation program, also runs on Ubuntu as well as Quick Books, our accounting software. In summary, all of our necessary software will run with Ubntu as it does on the current Windows 7 systems at the both the main and home offices.
I next evaluated Ubuntu in terms of its efficiency, its cost, and any potential advantages it held over its alternatives. Being free and easy to download via USB drive or CD, Ubuntu would not cost Santangelo Funeral Home any money if implemented. And, because Windows is compatible with Ubuntu, there would be no specific training costs associated, either. However, in addition to me, the other regular users of the Windows 7 system are not comfortable with new and innovative technology so they will likely hesitant to make the switch. Even though functions are similar or identical, appearance plays an important role and having mastery of a certain operating system helps boost confidence when completely tasts.  (I should note that Ubuntu offers a Business Desktop Remix but I was left feeling that it is aimed at serving a larger corporation than ours. It is geared more toward companies that have many more users than we do and allows employers to remove social networking applications if desired. While it may be important for some executives to take these measures to insure productivity, this is not a feature from which Santangelo Funeral Home would benefit.)
Ubuntu's efficiency is noticable. It is a dependable operating system that continues to improve and has already released 17 versions in the past 8 years with a new version introduced every 6 months. This type of productivity and innovation assures that Ubuntu is a sound option and is an operating system that certainly would not be problematic if adopted for regular use. Where Ubuntu separates itself from its alternatives (i.e. Windows and iOS) is with its interface and speed. It is a fast operating system that is uniquely sharp in its appearance. It seems to bridge the gap between Windows and Apple with its use of Applications in a format that appears more like Windows. That said, its speed is not significantly different enough to make a difference in time saving for our business. Santangelo Funeral Home generally does not require its employees to be working at the fastest rate possible - if anything, taking time to personalize work is something on which we pride ourselves. I actually feel concerned that having to oriente to a new interface could cause our employees to feel insecure and apprehensive to explore. I know that our employees know where to find things on the computer and how things look and making to changes to that could actually cause work to slow and may actually negatively impact productivity.
Overall, there is no harm in installing and using Ubuntu alongside or as an alternative to Windows 7 and iOS. However, because we have spent time with carefully "mastering" Windows 7 on all business computers (as well as use of the iPad and iPhones) I would advise that it is best not to introduce Ubuntu into the workplace. Despite it being free and easy to use, it does not offer anything we need or do not already have and may only instill hesitancy and insecurity in some of our employees.
*On a more personal note, Ubuntu may just be the perfect solution for a day when I have the itch for some new technology but my bank account reminds me to think again...