Sunday, April 21, 2013

Our Grand Brand

After our consultation Tuesday evening, I am excited about our prospects for increasing our narrowing margin within the gaming industry. I was so pleased to see that our current ROI on IT investment is estimated at 62% while our competitors property investment is a mere 15-23% in comparison. Clearly, our decision to invest in data mining was wise, progessive and successful. We have much to proud of.

As we begin to analyze our alternatives for increasing our revenues and securing our place in the industry, we should focus on our data mining skill. The consultants suggested that we increase our data mining to define a quality customer and to include greater marketing and mailing efforts. This should include my idea about email addresses and cell phone numbers being attached to customer information. Although I am not confident that we can guarentee the 50% response rate that was estimated, I do believe we have the potential for millions of dollars to be gained by further developing our marketing and data mining efforts as defined by the consultants.

The idea of implementing an online reservation and concierge is the recommendation I am most excited about. I think this works well with our data mining concept and helps to sync more customer data while offering a customized service to the Harrah's customer. With room choices, reservation selections, email addresses and cell phone numbers filtering into our system, our data mining software will be put into effect to better understand our customers and to customize Total Rewards accordingly. We need to research vendors to provide this online service in order to make sure we are choosing the most cost effective subscription plan with maximum services provided. 

The suggestion to enhance our data analytics to improve the delays between AS400 and UNIX Gateway is something I think should be revisited at another time. Despite the potential to perform an instant saneness test and to increase speed, I do not believe that this is the time to alter our analytics system. It is because of this system that we have earned such a high ROI. While I know this may be a viable option in the next 2-3 years, I think the focus now must be on the development of the website to include reservation and concierge services and also to incorporate further customer data mining information which will enhance our already successful system.

**Disclaimer: Please note that my previous suggestions regarding Smartphones and Facebook should not be considered. I was thinking way too far in to the future. Please consider this memo my final recommendation based on the Harrah's brand today. **

Thank you,
Emily Santangelo

Friday, April 19, 2013

Closing Pandora's Box

Good morning Mr. Westergren,

I hope that you were as pleased with Tuesday night's consultation as I was. I have confidence that by using the suggestions of these consultants, the future of Pandora is bright. That said, I would like to review their recommendations and measure them against some of mine.

First, I would like to throw out the option to sell the company (as did they). I think that making changes to Pandora today will make for much greater revenue in the years to come than a lump sum buy out.

Second, I was interested to see that increasing social media (via Facebook and Myspace) is not expected to bring in significant net revenue in comparison to our other options. I anticipated a greater return than the $358K expected after the first year. It seems that our plan of action should still include some focus on the social media spectrum but that alone will not be enough.

The consultants did not speak about the options for charging musicians/artists for either their music or their use of the Pandora services. After careful consideration I am concerned that implementing such fees may be contrary to the Pandora philosophy and spirit. There are enough changes we can make in an effort to draw higher revenue before we need to explore this option.

The recommendation to develop a tier structure as a means of increasing subscription revenue was an option I had not considered but was interested to learn about. While I am not sure that the design that was presented is the exact guideline to follow, I think that supscriptions are a reasonable way to keep the Pandora experience in tact while raising revenue. This deserves careful review and gradual implementation.

Audio advertisements were a topic I had suggested exploring. I was pleasantly surprised to see that the expected new revenue after two years is $10.5M! Advertising is an inevitable lifeline to website's survival and Pandora is no exception. I would like to see financials beyond those presented which only accounted for a 15 second advertisement. I think it is crucial that the advertisements cannot greatly alter the listener experience upon which Pandora users have grown to rely.

Last is the recommendation to invest in mobile application which was suggested by the consultants and me. This is certainly the wave of the future and will provide Pandora with the edge that will be needed to gain and maintain competitive advantage in the next few years.

Overall, I think Pandora should shift its focus to mobile application, subscription options and advertising options. Combined these effects should bring millions of dollars in net revenue within 2-3 years. The company will be able to enjoy positive cash-flow and investors will have confidence to re-invest and remain a part of this ever-growing Internet phenomenon.

I look forward to your response.

Best,
Emily Santangelo

Tuesday, April 16, 2013

Thinking out of the (Pandora) Box

Mr. Westergren,

Pandora Radio has been a successful music-recommendation service that allows users to listen to their favorite musical artists while gaining exposure to upcoming artists with similar musical attributes. Since it's launch in 1999, Pandora has been seeking to reach cash-flow positive status. With investors now doubtful in 2007,  you, Mr. Westergren, have fears to ease and confidence to foster. Pandora has made wise decisions and kept growing but what needs to change in order for revenue to grow enough to make a profit? With a current gross profit of $0.69 per hour, Pandora must find ways in which to grow this statistic to realize dollars (and eventually many dollars) per hour listened Internet-wide.

In terms of its company philosophy, Pandora is creative and innovative. By understanding musical DNA, Pandora uses collaborative filtering to create a serendipitous mood for listeners. By giving the opportunity for new artists to be heard while still enjoying current favorites, listeners can keep the mood set while staying fresh and new. But growing this user base is one way in which to minimize the fixed cost of the company.

Thus far, there has not been any significant investment in marketing. This is a segment that should be reviewed by Pandora executives at this time. Remembering that you need to spend money to make money, it is advisable to consider creating a small marketing team to discuss options for Pandora. I believe a modest budget can be developed that will likely translate into big returns for Pandora.

Another way to grow revenue is to alter the advertising experience on the website. Although users are pleased with the current advertising experience (and also have the opportunity to pay to opt out of receiving any at all), I would like our consultants to speak to our available options for altering this to answer Pandora's need to increase revenue.

A third option is to gain revenue by charging the artists directly. Although this may not seem like the perfect solution with regard to Pandora's ideals, the company must prove itself worthy of continued investment and the cash needs to flow in order to do so. Perhaps a nominal fee or one time fee can be paid by lesser known artists that want their music played on the website. To that end, Pandora could charge for use of its engine, The Music Genome Project. Artist's musical DNA can be analyzed for a fee.  This service may speak to to the "pull" method of music distribution as artists seek multiple arenas for promoting their music. Artists can use the information given to better understand its competition in the industry. That is a valuable service upon which Pandora could capitalize.  

While the above listed suggestions may be worthwhile considerations, the arena that I believe to hold the most potential for the growth of Pandora is that of the mobile experience. With the release of the first iPhone just six months ago (in June 2007), mobile applications are a hot topic among techies. Pandora should shift its focus to be available to listeners via cell phones/smartphones, other mobile devices that are in development, and in their cars. This would make Pandora accessible at all times, not only when a computer is readily available. The Squeezebox hardware is not enough to make Pandora flexible, transportable, and accessible. As people use their iPods (and now iPhones) to listen to music, so must they be able to do so with the Pandora experience. I foresee a Pandora future that has people listening at the gym, walking the dog, driving to work and throughout the day. With this switch to mobile accessibility, Pandora is sure to recognize a larger user base which will lower fixed costs. Further, advertisers will be more opt to pay higher prices to be a part of the Pandora experience. They will be willing to pay for a few seconds of interrupted music listening time to gain the exposure of listeners who are plugged in and on the move. With profitable revenues expected in the millions of dollars, Pandora can create marketing and IT budgets with it's cash flow after initial investments are paid off.

I look forward to the advice of this evenings consultation team. I am hoping that they focus their presentation on the mobile spectrum for Pandora while still including some of the above listed suggestions made here to you. I would specifically like to see the financials for investing in mobile application and how long it would like take to become cash-flow positive after that investment. I would like to review what we are doing best to insure that those successful aspects are not jeopardized by making changes to the Pandora style. I hope to be presented with options that are clearly defined in a step-by-step fashion so that we make sure each dollar spent is directly accounted for. While no company should ever spend money without careful thought, it is particularly critical for our dollars to be spent efficiently. An integration of mobile device use and automobile use will affect all Pandora users and employees. This seems to me to be the answer to the current dilema we face with revenues that are simply too low to sustain. I look foward to our meeting tomorrow after hearing a more careful presentation of our options by the consultants this evening. 

The Greek meaning of Pandora is "all-giving" which is the ultimate goal of this Internet company. I am confident we can reach this pinnacle.

Monday, April 15, 2013

Harrah's: The Sure Bet!

To my fellow executives:


When Harrah's developed its WINet technology it was the beginning of a bright and prosperous future for the company. In an effort to interconnect employees, executives, multiple casino locations and customers, Harrah's knew it needed to create a closed loop marketing system that integrated the Harrah's experience and hence created the Harrah's brand. This was a creative and innovative approach to gaining competitive advantage and market share. The basis for the new IT infrastructure was based on understanding customers and earning their loyalty as a means of guaranteeing that Harrah's would be the gamers' choice regardless of location. Usually a company's IT infrastructure is focused more on employees/users than it is on consumers. Instead, Harrah's design was created based on brand loyalty and marketing techniques making it a unique and efficient design. This was certainly a wise choice. 

Harrah's had the option to continue to use technology that resembled its competition but instead it underwent a multi-million dollar development of WINet. First the Patron Database (PDB) was used to serve as a "cross property view" to help identify and respond to market segments. WINet collects customer data from multiple sources and integrates that information to store it for future use. WINet was enhanced with the implementation of the Marketing Workbench (MWB) which served as a "data warehouse for analytical application". From 1994-2002 WINet was adapted, reconfigured, enhanced and implemented to create a nearly flawless technological architecture that interconnects player's information to create offers, rewards and customized information tailored for specific marketing needs. The IT investment has paid for itself over and over with hundreds of millions of dollars in revenue generated from it's brand development. By having an interconnected, closed-loop marketing system customer loyalty was created with the Total Rewards program which is considered "the world's largest database of casino customers". Customer retention is nothing to take likely in the casino gaming industry. According to the article, "an increase in retention of just 1% is work $2M in net profit annually". This is a huge impact for the company and a strong indicator that Harrah's has successfully gained a significant competitive advantage. It is clear that our data mining and closed-loop marketing technique was the right move. 

While Harrah's has much to be proud about in the development of the Total Rewards program success, it's IT must continue to evolve and adapt to new methods of market penetration. First we must reflect upon the impact that we have made on our business by data warehousing and data mining. We have learned that with the help of our BI/BA capabilities we have been able to segment our marketing, retain customers and strengthen their loyalty. We are able to "see" the results of successful targeted marketing and have used that to increase and maintain high revenues. However, as expected, our competitors are catching up and we now need to tailor our IT practices to maintain results and extend our success in the future. With the information we have from the MINet development we can now focus on new projects that will take Harrah's Total Rewards program to the next level.

My suggestions are as follows:

1. Creating a Total Rewards application to be used on mobile devices/Smartphones that will sync into our WINet architecture. For example, we need to see how our Total Rewards Program Card can take on a digital application option. Customers should be able to scan and use their mobile devices just as they used the loyalty card.

2. Developing a Facebook Rewards page that allows users to track specials, view promotions, and stay connected to deals and updates from the Harrah's brand. This should include the option to select specific casino locations that are frequented by gamers. Data mining should filter through Facebook to be included in the "closed loop marketing" system. 

3. Email addresses should also be included in the initial data captured and recorded along with the rest of the demographic information. Specials and promotions can be sent through email addresses and special offers can be sent virtually (not only via postal mail). The Patron Database can come into play with email address sign up just as it does for first time Harrah's property visitors. There should be links in these emails that allow tracking of offers being utilized just as they work now. There should be seamless integration between mobile applications and the rewards program that exists currently. 

These are just a few suggestions for ways in which the Harrah's brand can continue to positively influence changes in customer behavior with more up to the moment technology. I hope that the consultants can highlight areas in which our current system needs improvement. I am curious to see if there is any effect of human error from daily input of data. Further, this may be an area that can be improved with altering the system as it stands today. 

I am hoping to see additional suggestions to those I offer here as ways in which to increase industry margins to take more of an industry lead. By highlighting flaws and kinks in the system can we can seek to resolve those issues as we also plan new and innovative strategies to out perform our competitors. I look forward to consulting about email options, mobile applications, web presence and more so that Harrah's may take more of an industry lead in the next 2-3 years. 

I hope the consultants include financial estimates as to how much investment in additional IT would be necessary to draw returns on investment that we saw with the MINet development. We need to know our options, prioritize them, create a budget for each and estimate how much return we should expect to consider it a success. I look forward to tomorrow evenings consultation as we plan for Harrah's future. 

One thing is for sure: Harrah's will continue to use the Total Rewards program to secure its hold in the industry ... I'll bet on it! 

Monday, April 1, 2013

Microsoft Project

After using Project Professional 2013 as a trial, I have decided that is would not serve any useful purpose at Santangelo Funeral Home at this time. Microsoft Project is a highly efficient project management software program that is beneficial for developing and tracking the success of projects while allowing for active collaboration between project team members. Of the three version options (Standard, Professional, and Pro for Office 365), Standard is the version that would be most applicable to our business practices. The cost is $589.99 per computer which would mean $1,179.98 to our business in order to accommodate both the home and business offices.  Although this is a nominal cost, that is money that would be more efficiently used if directed toward our advertising and marketing budgets (which never seem to be large enough). With the Standard version we loose the ability to IM, virtually connect with other users, or sync through Office 365 which are only available on the other two versions. For Project Professional and Project Pro for Office 365, we would need to purchase Microsoft Lunch Online, SharePoint Online and possibly Project Online if we wanted to be able to maximize use of all features. Because we do not currently work in teams or on specific long-term and budgeted projects, Microsoft Project (MP) would be a useless expense that would not help daily business routines or productivity.

However, if we were to open a funeral home in another location I would consider purchasing MP as a way to collaborate between offices via the cloud. It would be an effective way to track funeral services at each location in an organized fashion with use of the tracking charts and spreadsheets. This would ensure seamless communication between offices and allow real-time access to each office. Assuming a second location would be set-up similarly to our current business, we can assume an additional $589.99  if we were to use the Standard version. It is likely that we would like to use some of the features of the Professional version which would be a cost of $3,479.97 ($1,159.99x3 computers - based upon today's pricing). However, that is still a one-time purchasing cost that would be worthwhile to achieve collaboration and planning between multiple locations.

In summary, although MP is a user-friendly and efficient software program, its features would not enhance current daily practices at Santangelo Funeral Home. Having spent time exploring the software, I am confident that it is a feature that would be worthwhile in the future if the company is able to expand to multiple locations.

Bombardier Decision

To my fellow executives:

Some interesting thoughts were stirred during our consultation regarding our next ERP implementation. I was pleased to be presented with the 12 Best Practices list that I knew Bombardier should use during this next phase. I think the consultants were generous in their rating of Bombardier's current practices by giving us ratings of all 2s and 3s which defined either no deficiency or a minor deficiency. It was interesting to compare their ratings with my initial evaluation. Practice #3 (ERP software implementation responsibilities should be shared between the IT department and functional areas where the software is being implemented) was labeled as a minor deficiency by the consultants and was also an area on which I stated attention should be focused. However, they also advised that #6, #9, and #11 needed improvement whereas I had focused on improving #8 and #10. 


To improve #3, #9 and #11, the team suggested we include functional specialists in design and implementation activities as well as a diversified support team. While this would cost $145,500 I would suggest we implement this suggestion based upon the expected benefit of $560,000 in the long run. I think it is best to identify the employees that could easily become specialists and to create a team of these specialists to help their co-workers. It was also suggested that we set in place a formal process for scorecard progress to insure accurate, real-time updates. This is something I think is certainly advisable. The entire framework of ERP depends upon accuracy and constant accessibility so sharpening this process will enhance our system. The expected benefit is also $1,300 per scorecard which is significant enough to indicate a worthwhile improvement. Next we are advised to hire SAP developers as we phase out of our dependence on consultants. This should be a great financial savings that is worth investigating further. I do think that it is important to more accurately break down the costs for hiring when considering required benefits, supplies needed, and space needed, etc for that many more full-time employees of Bombardier. The consultants were not thorough enough for me to be convinced that this should quickly be acted upon.  Last, they suggested that we establish a "broad but standardized contract process and expand the SAP features to accommodate the improved process". This should seek to improve #11 (The institution should change its administrative processes to fit the software). I am not convinced that there was a clear way presented to us Tuesday night. It seems that the expected benefits of fitting the new software is anywhere between $125K-$250K but we should research the subtleties in the different options and evaluate which is best in the long term. Although the consultants did not speak much about our training process, I do believe that top-management needs to be actively engaged in the training and development process from start to end. We must also have a solid support system for the first 6 months so that employee productivity is not affected. If employees are well trained and have proper assistance when needed, resistance and hesitance will be kept at a minimum. 


Bombardier should use our first and second implementations as a guide and seek to follow the advice of our hired consultants to guide our actions. Equally as important as making changes is focusing on what we've done well and ensuring that those practices are protected. If too much time and/or energy is placed on improving and changing, we run the risk of loosing our best skills. Although a third ERP should be better than the previous two, we should still focus on what we've done best and what works best so that this ERP rollout has a strong foundation upon which to improve. Generally, the best predictor of future behavior is past behavior, so it is important to identify the kinks and embrace the success.