To my fellow executives:
Some interesting thoughts were stirred during our consultation regarding our next ERP implementation. I was pleased to be presented with the 12 Best Practices list that I knew Bombardier should use during this next phase. I think the consultants were generous in their rating of Bombardier's current practices by giving us ratings of all 2s and 3s which defined either no deficiency or a minor deficiency. It was interesting to compare their ratings with my initial evaluation. Practice #3 (ERP software implementation responsibilities should be shared between the IT department and functional areas where the software is being implemented) was labeled as a minor deficiency by the consultants and was also an area on which I stated attention should be focused. However, they also advised that #6, #9, and #11 needed improvement whereas I had focused on improving #8 and #10.
To improve #3, #9 and #11, the team suggested we include functional specialists in design and implementation activities as well as a diversified support team. While this would cost $145,500 I would suggest we implement this suggestion based upon the expected benefit of $560,000 in the long run. I think it is best to identify the employees that could easily become specialists and to create a team of these specialists to help their co-workers. It was also suggested that we set in place a formal process for scorecard progress to insure accurate, real-time updates. This is something I think is certainly advisable. The entire framework of ERP depends upon accuracy and constant accessibility so sharpening this process will enhance our system. The expected benefit is also $1,300 per scorecard which is significant enough to indicate a worthwhile improvement. Next we are advised to hire SAP developers as we phase out of our dependence on consultants. This should be a great financial savings that is worth investigating further. I do think that it is important to more accurately break down the costs for hiring when considering required benefits, supplies needed, and space needed, etc for that many more full-time employees of Bombardier. The consultants were not thorough enough for me to be convinced that this should quickly be acted upon. Last, they suggested that we establish a "broad but standardized contract process and expand the SAP features to accommodate the improved process". This should seek to improve #11 (The institution should change its administrative processes to fit the software). I am not convinced that there was a clear way presented to us Tuesday night. It seems that the expected benefits of fitting the new software is anywhere between $125K-$250K but we should research the subtleties in the different options and evaluate which is best in the long term. Although the consultants did not speak much about our training process, I do believe that top-management needs to be actively engaged in the training and development process from start to end. We must also have a solid support system for the first 6 months so that employee productivity is not affected. If employees are well trained and have proper assistance when needed, resistance and hesitance will be kept at a minimum.
Bombardier should use our first and second implementations as a guide and seek to follow the advice of our hired consultants to guide our actions. Equally as important as making changes is focusing on what we've done well and ensuring that those practices are protected. If too much time and/or energy is placed on improving and changing, we run the risk of loosing our best skills. Although a third ERP should be better than the previous two, we should still focus on what we've done best and what works best so that this ERP rollout has a strong foundation upon which to improve. Generally, the best predictor of future behavior is past behavior, so it is important to identify the kinks and embrace the success.
No comments:
Post a Comment