Friday, March 8, 2013

Accenture Decision Memo

Fellow executives,

Our meeting with the consulting group on Tuesday evening solidified my decision that now is not the time to implement COBIT 5. In addition to the concerns I share with these consultants, they also noted that COBIT 5 is a generalized framework and suggested this may be an imperfect tool for such a highly personalized and well-developed IT system as we have at Accenture. 

To speak to my concern on the costs associated with COBIT 5, the consultants carefully itemized the expenses for training based on 500 employees to be between $1.7M and $2.3M. I would add that in a company with tens of thousands of employees 500 employees is a low-end estimate of the actual number of employees requiring training. In addition to the training costs, the team also suggested the additional personnel required for a 3-year implementation program would cost an additional $15M. Although the number of new employees hired and the salary they are paid may be altered, COBIT 5 still seems to require additional employees and at no small cost to Accenture. Before listening to the consultants, I had not accounted for the need to hire additional employees. Therefore, hearing this further convinced me that COBIT 5 would be an unnecessary expense for Accenture to incur at this time. 

While the consultants were clear and thorough in their presentation, I would like to reiterate my previous concern about the effects of this adaption on current employees. Although there is no direct dollar amount to attach to this area of hesitation, I believe it carries significant weight. Employees who have worked laboriously and diligently to create Accenture's stellar IT program could easily feel frustrated, under appreciated and resentful if a new framework were to be adopted. Let's not forget that these are the people who brought us to the level of success we are currently enjoying. 

In conclusion, I urge you to evaluate the costs (both monetary and emotional) associated with a COBIT 5 implementation. Once again, I offer my opinion that Accenture will not currently benefit from COBIT 5 and in fact, it will be a cost that I forecast to be detrimental to a well-crafted infrastructure. 

No comments:

Post a Comment