My fellow Accenture team:
In preparation for our meeting with the consulting firm tomorrow evening, I wanted to review our current position and consider what our options are. I hope that the consultation firm will be able to provide greater insight into our options and help guide a decision about maintaining the IT sector of Accenture.
As a global enterprise, Accenture has been exemplar in its transformation to an ERP system and in developing a business-within-a-business IT system and implementing the Global Delivery Network. From 2001 to 2010 we more than doubled our number of IT employees, our revenue doubled, and we increased the percentage of satisfied sponsors. All this while reducing IT money spent overall and as a percentage of revenue and per person. We decreased the number of global and local applications and switched from multiple technology platforms to just one. We are now faced with options on how to best maintain these results while staying true to the effective and flexible platform upon which Accenture designed its infrastructure. It is important to remember that this decision will be of a global and company-wide scope thus affecting thousands of employees around the world.
Accenture has the option to implement the use of Control Objectives for Information and Related Technology (COBIT 5). According to its homepage, COBIT 5 is "the latest edition of ISACA’s globally accepted framework, providing an end-to-end business view of the governance of enterprise IT that reflects the central role of information and technology in creating value for enterprises. The principles, practices, analytical tools and models found in COBIT 5 embody thought leadership and guidance from business, IT and governance experts around the world." Further, COBIT 5 divides IT into the following divisions: Plan and Organize, Acquire and Implement, Deliver and Support, and Monitor and Evaluate. After our IT transformation, Accenture is currently independently managing these subdivisions already. There is great similarity in the practices of Accenture and the description of what COBIT 5 offers, namely in the planning, management, and execution of IT practices such as the use of a single-vendor platform as with the current ERP. Our business relationship with sponsors is already sound and our support expenses have decreased. Our current governance structure that is subdivided into strategy and structure, multi-year planning, annual planning and execution already includes most of what COBIT 5 offers. However, it's important to at least consider what COBIT 5 may offer Accenture in 2013 and beyond. That said, when deciding if Accenture should implement COBIT 5, we must determine the decision criteria. Does COBIT 5:
- allow Accenture to maintain its existing IT infrastructure: YES
- allow Accenture to maintain its IT independence: YES
- require changes to the existing global ERP: NO
- disturb the business within a business structure that currently exists: NO
- keep Accenture flexible and efficient: NO
- support the ROI-orientation of the current IT budgets: NO
As you can see above, COBIT 5 becomes a risk to Accenture in terms of its cost to the company as well as the potential effects its adoption could have on employees. Implementing COBIT 5 would cost Accenture thousands of dollars in training. This money would have to be carefully budgeted to uphold the current IT practices. By adopting COBIT 5, Accenture would be loosing some of its independence. After the tremendous re-organzation and development of the IT structure, I am hesitant for Accenture to now implement a new and different framework. A greater concern is for the thousands of employees who are currently maintaining and governing Accenture's IT "business". Changing to COBIT 5 would mean not only training these individuals but also matching the confidence level they currently posses. All this without gaining anything that is necessary to improve or enhance Accenture.
It is my hope that the consultants present the details about the offerings of COBIT 5 and how it would be similar and different from the current governance structure. A comparison chart would be very helpful in illustrating the pros and cons of a COBIT 5 system. I would also like to see a more specific breakdown of the costs associated with the potential implementation. We need to know exactly what is necessary to make this adoption and the costs associated with each.
After we hear the presentation by these consultants we should meet to review and decide if COBIT 5 will be implemented or if Accenture should continue to perform as is. It will take significant convincing to sway me toward COBIT 5. I do not see any ways in which it will enhance the infrastructure we so carefully developed and am concerned it may introduce complication and concern to our exemplar team.
For your reference: http://www.isaca.org/COBIT/Pages/default.aspx
No comments:
Post a Comment