What is the problem?
Ray D'Alonzo is faced with a decision about how the clinical trial process can be improved and made more efficient. The current paper-based trial practice is too lengthy and in need of an overhaul to work more effectively. D'Alonzo needs to develop a system that allows trial preparation to occur in a more time-effective manner while increasing overall profit.
What is the distinction between the problems and the symptoms?
The symptoms of this problem include human error when completing the paper-based data collection, long verification processing time, multiple steps in data verification, and an overall delay trial preparation.
What is the scope of the problem?
The problem is focused around the time delay and the extensive manual labor required. The way the data is collected and processed needs to be improved while the information itself stays the same. The issue is centered around the process of data collection and review, not the content of the data.
What are the decision criteria?
D'Alonzo must consider the cost-benefit analysis of switching to a different system. He must evaluate how it impacts the staff members and the trial participants. He must develop criteria that addresses the time difference, the monetary difference, and the overall ease of either improving the current system or adopting a new one. He needs to find the system that offers long-term benefits that can be sustained.
What are the alternative courses of action?
D'Alonzo basically has three alternatives. He can improve the current paper-based process, he can switch to digital imaging or he can choose the use of Web-enabled EDC.
How does each of these address the key problem?
Improving the current paper-based process may be able to reduce the time spent and it may be the least expensive option in the short term, however it does not eliminate the issue of human error and potential discrepancies. In fact, this would require increased staffing to mail shipments daily. Although staff may feel most comfortable staying with a paper-based system, it would not alter the system drastically enough to see significant change in the problems. The digital imaging process brings about issues with memory and capacity as well as storing and tracking. However, the delays in processing were still not resolved. Essentially there would be great cost in investing in data storage facilities without shortening the review time. The EDC option allowed the data to be directly imputed to the investigation sites. No double entry was necessary and the speed of the process was improved.
Through what theoretical concepts should one evaluate the alternatives?
Useful concepts include a cost-benefit analysis, employee impacts, time involved, and accuracy measured.
How does the evaluation relate to the decision criteria developed?
The criteria listed above directly relates to these concepts. D'Alonzo needs to find the option that offers the most long-term financial improvements while being able to train employees and improve the accuracy of the data processing. While doing so, he wants to insure P&G will have financial growth by increasing the speed of the data processing.
How imaginative can/should the evaluation be?
The evaluation in this case should be quite straight forward without much in the way of creativity and imagination. The alternatives are clearly defined and the results should be evaluated and transferred into a decision.
What is the quality recommendation?
What is the logical recommendation?
Both the quality and logical recommendation for D'Alonzo is to switch to the EDC system. With this option there is higher quality data and greater compensation for P&G. Evaluated through a long-term lens, the results indicate that the data collection and processing is far quicker and more accurate with the EDC system.
If I were presenting, how would I sum up the case?
What key visual aids would I present?
How would I "sell" the recommendation?
What other delivery considerations should I keep in mind?
In presenting this case, I would focus on the results of the EDC system and the ways in which the time saved will transfer to higher profits. Visual aids of the paper-based, Digital Imagine and EDC options would be helpful while presenting the options. I think it is important to articulate the pros and cons of each alternative to insure that the ultimate decision took into account a full analysis of the options. I would conclude by restating the main problem and how the EDC option directly resolves this with efficiency and cost-effectiveness.
No comments:
Post a Comment